Seifert Surfaces

Description

Using knots made out of wire, students will see what happens when they dip them into bubble-making solutions. They will experience the idea of a surface, and they will experience how the study of knots can be taken in amazing directions.

Materials

Instructions

Ideas for discussion

Materials

Instructions

  1. Have students dip trefoil knots into the bubble solution and examine carefully the way the soap film clings to the wire. Ask students to describe what they see.
  2. The form of the stretched and twisted soap film is called a Seifert Surface . Notice that it has two sides, a "front" and a "back". When you hold the surface up, which parts face you? You can draw an accurate representation of the surface by using two colors, one for each side.
  3. Ask students to choose another knot that they would like to twist from the wire and examine the soap film that it will make. Before dipping the knot into the bubble mixture, have students predict the surface that they think will form.
  4. Experiment with other knot-shaped bubble makers and catalog the surfaces that form.

Ideas for Discussion

  1. Describe what happens when various knots are dipped. Why do you think this occurs?
  2. Does the same surface always form when knots are dipped? Is there a way you can be sure that no surfaces other than the ones you have discovered will ever form when a knot is dipped?
  3. How can you account for the things that you observe?